Boing Boing posted a summary of an editorial somewhere about P2P. I have to admit: I still don't get it.
What's the point of having legal P2P music downloads? It just makes no sense. Legal music should come from fast servers with insane amount of bandwidth, not from some motley band of dailup users and people with stuttering connections.
The reason P2P works for non-legal stuff is because everyone contributes some music, thus increasing choice. Some people may have better copies then others, and that might increase file-size, which may or may not be a problem for someone downloading. So there is choice in that sense too.
In case of legal downloads "all" music is basically available and in good quality. What's the need for using P2P here? If there is only one near-perfect copy, what is the need for having everyone share it? Bandwidth? Come on! The world is flush with bandwidth! There is so much bandwidth we have to invent things like "Internet 2" and "Telepresence" etc. just to have an excuse to use some more of it.
The price of the bandwidth needed to transfer a song is totally negligable compared to the 99 cents or whatever the song costs.
If someone were to charge 99 cents for a song that is distributed via P2P you would basically be ripped off, as there is no investment required by the distributor at all anymore. No website needed, no bandwidth to pay for etc. Perhaps that might be something that appeals to the distributors of course, but it should not appeal to the average consumer.
Another argument is that people can choose to share what they like and that you could use that in a kind of FOAF way to find new music. This is basically nonsense too, because P2P is largely anonymous. You don't know the person (or persons) that has the file you are downloading. Oftentimes you don't even notice his nickname or whatever. This basically means that this is not some kind of blogosphere filtering/FOAF/social network aggregation/etc. thing. Of course one could modify the software to work more in that kind of a way, but what is the point? Every legal music store has Amazon-style suggestions ("If you like this, also try...") which are more or less the same thing.
Am I missing something here or is this really just yet another misguided idea taken up by the media?